July 21, 2024


Learn new things

An Open Letter to Josh Shapiro Asking Him to Reject School Vouchers 


Pricey Josh Shapiro, 

Are you for general public instruction or not?

I only talk to due to the fact as the Democratic prospect for Governor in Pennsylvania, you come off as the savior of colleges and youngsters on the campaign path.

You say you want to increase state funding to general public schools. Wonderful!

You say you want to reduce standardized tests. Excellent!

You want to assurance each and every college student has access to technological and vocational classes and make guaranteed every school building has at least one focused psychological overall health counselor on workers. Remarkable!

But in interviews and on your campaign Web page, you say you’re in favor of college vouchers!


Did Charles Koch just hack your election headquarters? Is Betsy DeVos impersonating you in the media?

Because supporting faculty vouchers does not healthy in at all with a person who claims to champion general public schooling.

General public education and learning signifies public colleges. It implies tax bucks remaining used to fund community educational institutions and these educational institutions currently being run by elected university boards.

It does not indicate tax pounds heading to non-public and parochial schools. It does not indicate our dollars likely to establishments in which we get no say in how it’s expended. It does not indicate circumventing duly elected faculty boards. It does not necessarily mean the general public shelling out for spiritual indoctrination or the type of right wing biased education routinely supplied at personal universities.

But that’s what faculty vouchers do.

They steal taxpayer pounds from genuine community educational institutions and allow for them to be squandered on non-public and parochial universities. They wipe out any accountability for how our collective funds is invested and do really serious damage to thousands of the most having difficulties genuine public university students even though lining the pockets of private companies and religious establishments.

And the separation of church and condition – fail to remember about it!

This does not seem like the candidate academics like me have been backing considering that before this election cycle commenced. Frankly, it’s virtually what your gubernatorial opponent, MAGA Republican Doug Mastriano, champions.

Mastriano – a Trump insurrectionist – claims he wants to use state education and learning funding to give Each individual university student a university voucher they can use at virtually any school in the Commonwealth – general public, non-public or parochial.

You feel to want vouchers ONLY for college students at the most underfunded and having difficulties colleges.

Nicely which is some distinction!

In its place of supplying a lot more help to the most inequitably funded educational facilities, you want to slash their funding even far more in the title of some old time Republican approach to allow a few escape a terrible situation even though the rest all drown!?

That is repulsive!

On your your campaign Internet site it suggests

 Josh favors incorporating alternatives for moms and dads and educational prospect for students and funding lifeline scholarships like those people permitted in other states and launched in Pennsylvania. 

In an interview in the Patriot Information you say

 “And I’m for generating positive we insert scholarships like lifeline scholarships to make confident that that’s additive to their education. That it offers them other opportunities…to be able to enable them obtain success”  

These so-called Lifeline Scholarships are a Republican guide measure to give direct-to-pupil tax-funded scholarships that dad and mom and guardians in the state’s most neglected general public educational facilities could use for a variety of choices such as heading toward tuition at a distinct faculty.

The GOP sponsored bill handed the point out Dwelling of Reps in April on a 104-98 vote and cleared the condition Senate Instruction Committee in June. On the other hand, for the reason that of an amendment to safeguard low doing charter educational facilities from shedding their funding, it would nonetheless want final passage votes in both chambers ahead of getting to present Gov. Tom Wolf’s desk where by he would just about definitely veto it.

It would have an impact on about 191,000 pupils in 382 educational institutions, throughout 76 of the state’s 500 faculty districts. Even so, Two-thirds of the value of the plan (63.1%) is born by four districts – Philadelphia (43.9%), Looking through (8.9%), Allentown (5.8%) and Pittsburgh (4.5%).

This would develop yet another taxpayer funded program of education and learning. Affected districts would get rid of so significantly funding it would ultimately force them to reduce programs, services, and staffing and/or elevate home taxes to compensate.

What’s more, these would be the most neglected districts, and so the least capable to support the expense.

It’s a horrible strategy, and I can’t fully grasp why you would buck the frustrating the vast majority of your celebration and would-be constituents to assist it.

Is it due to the fact you deliver your possess young ones to a religion-centered private school, and that you are the merchandise of just these kinds of an education and learning, on your own?

This is how you reduce votes, Sir.

Your opponent is probably the most odious person to at any time run for Governor in the point out. He appears to be to usher in an era of theocratic fascism, curtail human legal rights and get the Commonwealth back to the Center Ages.

But that does not signify you ought to operate nearer to his positions in the vain hope of thieving some of his foundation.

The MAGA Republicans will hardly ever vote for you. Dressing by yourself up in their garments will not assist you do anything at all but disgust your individual supporters until some simply cannot bring themselves to vote at all.

As election working day nears, the polls get closer and nearer between Mastriano and you.

Pennsylvanians simply cannot afford to pay for shedding their only opportunity at self rule simply because of demoralization and despair at a candidate much too weak to assistance the platform he started this campaign on – championing general public education.

I urge you to reconsider this flirtation with Republican values and faculty vouchers.

I hope you are better than this.

We should have a governor who is much better than this.

You should have the braveness to stand by genuine general public universities.


Steven Singer

Like this submit?  You could possibly want to look at getting a Patreon subscriber. This can help me keep on to maintain the website going and get on with this difficult and difficult function.

Moreover you get subscriber only extras!

Just Simply click Below.


I’ve also created a e book, “Gadfly on the Wall: A General public School Trainer Speaks Out on Racism and Reform,” now accessible from Garn Push. 10 percent of the proceeds go to the Badass Instructors Affiliation. Verify it out!